Doing a literature review

It is important to carry out a review of the literature to allow you to acquire an understanding of your topic. You can become aware of the key issues, and relevant research that has already been done relating to your topic and find out the latest information.

Searching, evaluating and selecting from the vast range of published information can be a time-consuming process, so it is important to know how to plan and carry out this task effectively.

A literature search needs to be systematic and focused – you are not looking to read everything in a broad area, only things that are relevant to your work.

A literature search must also be evaluative - you need to critically assess each reference found to determine if it is worth pursuing and then critical read it.

The aim of the below is to help you to do this. You generally need to work through the following stages:

Doing a literature review

A green thumbnail for 'Basic search strategies' video with the UWL logo and title.

Basic search strategies (part 1)

A green thumbnail for 'Basic search stategies' video with the UWL logo and title.

Basic search strategies (part 2)

A green thumbnail for 'Evaluating your search results' video with the UWL logo and title.

Evaluating your search results

  • 1. Define your topic

    Following the advice provided by your module team or supervisor on the topic for the assignment, make sure you understand what is being asked of you. Clarify the meaning of the topic and particular words, using general or subject specific dictionaries/encyclopaedias if necessary.

    Consider what you already know in this area and what you might need to understand more before you start you’re searching. A general text book on the area will provide you with background information to help understand more about the topic before you do any detailed searching.

  • 2. Decide on scope

    If the subject area/topic is too general you may need to choose a specific aspect of it otherwise there will be too much literature for you to read and evaluate. Always check with your module study guide/lecturers what they are expecting you to cover in the assignment and whether they have set you any parameters to work within, for example a date range, specific methodology etc.

    Think about constraints, for example:

    • How long your project/essay needs to be and are you required to do within it. If you need to refer to published literature all the way through the essay you will need more sources than when you are also writing up practical work you have conducted.
    • How much time you have and what you can feasible read in this time period.
    • What help and resources you might need and whether they are available to you. Build in time to ask for support in using resources that you are unfamiliar with.
  • 3. Draw up a list of keywords

    Define your topic in terms of keywords to use for searching the various information sources. There are different ways to approach this task including making lists of words, diagrams or mind maps. Chose a method that works for you.

    In order to make your search as comprehensive as possible, you should think about the following:

    • Broader and narrower terms to the concepts you are searching on
    • Layman terms, medical teams and technical terms that could have been used by the author
    • Words that may be used as alternatives for your topic (synonyms) e.g. 'staff or employees' or 'work or employment'
    • Alternative spellings, particularly American ones, e.g. 'labour or labor'
    • Possible truncations e.g. manage* will retrieve manage(ment), manage(rs) and manage(rial)

    Look at ways to link your keywords. Boolean searching is the name given to the method of searching that uses the words AND, OR and NOT as operators to link keywords in a logical way to include or exclude certain terms.

    OR is a good technique to use when there are different ways of expressing the same term, for example

    "heart attack" OR "Myocardial infarction".

    Once you have your words, you need to organise them and combine them together when searching in the databases and search engines.

    If you have a phrase and you want the search engine to treat it as a phrase, the general rule is to enclose it in speech marks, for example "global warming".

  • 4. Set limits to your search

    Set limits to your search, for example:

    • Publication date - how far back do you want to search?
    • Range - what types of publication or documentation do you wish to include? Do you want to include newspaper articles, data sources, statistics for example?
    • Geographical - do you want to limit your search to material relating to a particular country or other geographical area?
    • How much do you need to find - the number of sources you need to consult will depend on the length of assignment and type of assignment
    • What methodologies you would like the research you are finding to have used

    Draw up a list of sources/databases to search and carry out your searches.

  • 5. Draw up a list of sources/databases to search

    Now that you know the subject areas you want to find information on, you can see which sources will contain information on these topics. Sources may be print-based others digital.

    For some topics, certain sources will offer you more information than others. Consider where an author may have published or made available information on your topic, what would have been the logical place open for that author to use. For academic authors, this could be books, journals, conference papers; for information from industry that might be online reports, magazines, websites.

    We have created subject-specific guides to resources in the Library to help you understand where you can search. As well as providing information about how to obtain material relevant to your subject, they supply links to some of the resources increasingly available electronically.

  • 6. Carry out your searches

    The Library search engine, LibSearch, is a quick way to begin your search for subject information and to identify the key sources for your subject.  It allows you to search the book collection, databases, and collections of e-journals and newspaper articles all at the same time. It's a great starting point for your research. However, you may also need to do more detailed searching via individual electronic databases.

    Consider the formats you think will provide useful information and then chose the search engine/database that would provide results from that format.

    Always keep in mind it is quality not quantity that it key.

    Keep a record of your searches. An essential part of literature searching is keeping accurate, consistent and correct records.

    Record all useful references. The useful references should be recorded from print-based sources or marked and downloaded from electronic databases. A detailed record of everything useful you find will enable you to provide an accurate reference list at the end of your project and in-text citations throughout your work.

  • 7. Review progress

    It is important to carry out a review of your progress after an initial search.

    • Have you found material that is likely to be relevant to your topic?
    • Evaluate what you have found in terms of relevance, reliability, currency, limitations and bias. It is the quality, not the quantity of the material that counts.
    • How many different voices are represented in the literature you have discovered?
    • How many different ideas/thoughts/differences have you found?
    • What is limiting you finding certain authors, ideas, outputs? Often this comes down to where you are searching and the keywords you are using

    Once you have reviewed what you have found, refer back to your original plan and decide whether you need to do more searching. If you do, consider whether you need to adapt the keywords you are using and the search engines/databases.

  • 8. Obtain copies of useful references

    It is very important to allow sufficient time to obtain copies of useful references. Most databases will have a mixture of full-text articles and bibliographic citations plus abstracts (summaries) of articles. Check LibSearch to see if the Library stocks the items you require. If the items you require are not available in full text via our Library they may be obtained via Inter-Library Loan, but make sure you have enough time before ordering.

  • 9. Read, evaluate and absorb

    The quality of the information you will find when searching will vary enormously depending on the sources you use. Therefore, it is important to be able to distinguish between the types of information you have found, evaluate what you have found and read it critically. Some questions to think about:

    • Is this a primary or secondary text? (i.e. is it the original research/source of information or is it an evaluation/summary/discussion text) Both will be useful in your research, you just need to be sure which one you are reading.
    • Who is the author and what is their authority in the subject area?
    • When was it written? (i.e. is it still relevant to today, is it out of date and so should be disregarded or is it seminal (so ground breaking/influential to the research that took place after it was written)
    • Why was it written? (i.e. what influences/biases do you need to be aware of)
    • What limits are there to the work? (i.e. what did the authors of the work set out to research, what were they not able to cover? What bearing does that have for your research?)
    • Does it agree / disagree with what you already knew or have read? Note these differences down
    • What is the evidence? (i.e. make sure you are not just reading the conclusions and that the author is backing up their statements)
    • Are they quoting others work or their own? If they are quoting the work of others, do follow this up and find the original source (if you can) as this will provide you with further context and detail.

    Make sure you are noting down the arguments/evidence not just summary sentences so that you can refer in your work to the core of the information source.

    Also make sure you are reading actively and keep testing yourself. Can you close the source and remember the key things it was mentioning and explain them to someone else. This is a good sign you have understood the source and will help with paraphrasing and referencing the work in your assignment.

    Keep notes are you are reading. Within your own writing, you will quite often be combining sources together, for example ones that agree about certain points, ones that have contrasting views etc, so try and see whether you can do this in your notes to make it easier when you start doing your writing. This could be in the form of a summary table.

  • 10. Write up your work

    Writing needs to be accompanied by a properly formatted reference list and in-text citations. Please refer to the correct referencing style guide for your subject (APA, OSCOLA or Harvard Cite Them Right).

Referencing

When you are quoting from or referring to someone else's work, from whatever source, you must make this clear to the reader. Failure to give credit to other people's work correctly could be considered plagiarism, which could lay you open to a disciplinary procedure.

Referencing style
We predominantly use Harvard Cite Them Right.

American Psychological Association (APA) is used by Psychology and other related subjects whilst OSCOLA is used by Law.
If you are unsure which style to use, please check with your lecturer.

 

What is Cite Them Right online?

Cite Them Right online is a comprehensive referencing guide that helps you cite and reference resources you use in your assignments. It includes examples of how to reference many different types of resources, and also provides numerous tips and frequently asked questions, covering different referencing scenarios.

How do I access Cite Them Right online?
You can access Cite Them Right remotely. Please log in using your staff or student ID and password.

What is RefWorks?

RefWorks is a web-based referencing management software, which comes with thousands of referencing styles. Users can export references quickly and easily from LibSearch, major online databases, Google Scholar, and from websites. Imported references can be placed in folders or projects and shared with UWL students, researchers, and faculty members. In-text citations can be added and bibliographies generated on MS Word and Google Docs.

The thumbnail says "Library How To Series: RefWorks - Creating an account" with basic illustration of person holding a lightbulb. There is a link to the UWL website and the UWL logo in the top left corner.

Login from here to RefWorks

To create a RefWorks account, click on the login link below and click on ‘Create account’. Enter your University of West London email address and follow the on-screen instructions which include choosing a password. You will be sent an Activation email to complete the process.

From then on login via your institution. Select the University of West London from the drop-down menu and login with your student number (username) followed by your password.

  • How do I use RefWorks?

    We use the ‘Cite them Right’ form of the Harvard style. You should ensure that you select this style before trying to format word-processed documents (e.g. in MS Word).

  • I am already working with the older Legacy RefWorks (orange)

    If you are already working with the older Legacy RefWorks (orange), you are advised to migrate your work to new RefWorks (blue). Access to the older version will be withdrawn shortly.

  • Importing references from EndNote or EndNote Web into RefWorks

    RefWorks allows you to upload references in an EndNote library (versions 8 or higher), or if stored in EndNote Web you can export them from EndNote and then import them into RefWorks. For instructions, see ‘Converting from other Bibliographic Management Programs’ in the RefWorks help file.

    Please note: Users may experience problems using RefWorks with Internet Explorer. We advise using a different internet browser.

Copyright information

Students completing their work in a booth in the library

Copyright is part of the Intellectual Property family and provides legal protection for:

  • original literary, dramatic, musical and artistic work, including illustration and photography
  • original non-literary written work, such as software, web content and databases
  • sound and music recordings
  • film and television recordings
  • broadcasts
  • the layout of published editions of written, dramatic and musical works

Get in touch

Student reading in library

In-person: Visit the Help Zone, ground floor at our Ealing & Reading sites. Find out the library opening hours.

Email us: library@uwl.ac.uk

Social media: Twitter

Telephone:  Ealing: 020 8231 2405  /  Reading: 020 8209 4434  (Mon-Fri 9am-5pm)

Need help? Chat with us.